VIEW LARGER President of Navajo Nation Dr. Buu Nygren in Window Rock, Ariz., on Thursday, Aug. 15, 2024. A preliminary investigation into sexual harassment allegations against Navajo Nation President Buu Nygren has cleared him of any wrongdoing, according to a report released by the Navajo Nation’s attorney general.
The investigation, which lasted eight months, concluded that the claims made by Vice President Richelle Montoya were unwarranted and did not meet the criteria for harassment under tribal policies.
Nygren responded to the findings in a statement, calling the allegations a "disgraceful power grab" and accusing Montoya of spreading false claims at community meetings. He also alleged that she collaborated with a recall committee in an effort to discredit his administration.
"Her actions have not only divided our Navajo Nation but hinder and undermine all the great work the administration has done and is doing," Nygren said.
Attorney General Ethel Branch, who oversaw the investigation, announced she had terminated the Tempe-based law firm hired to handle the case. Branch criticized the firm for delays in releasing the report, which she said exacerbated instability within Navajo government.
“The Navajo Nation deserves legal counsel that is diligent and that does its work in a manner that is appropriate to the level of care and attention that is warranted,” Branch wrote.
She added that she would not pursue further investigation into Montoya’s allegations, stating that continuing to spend tribal funds on the matter was not in the Nation’s best interest.
In addition, on Monday, Branch filed an application with the Special Division of the Window Rock District Court for the appointment of a Special Prosecutor to investigate serious allegations of misconduct involving CKP Insurance and certain tribal officials. According to Branch, a preliminary investigation revealed possible violations of federal and Navajo law, necessitating a full investigation.
“Considering the extraordinary circumstances relating to this matter, I have concluded it is in the public interest to request a Special Prosecutor,” Branch said. “I take seriously allegations of misconduct that harm the Nation, and this confirms my commitment to protect the Nation’s interests under the law.”
The Special Prosecutor, once appointed, will operate independently from the Navajo Department of Justice but must comply with tribal laws and procedures.
However, shortly after the findings of the sexual harassment case were released, the Navajo Nation Council voted to remove Branch from her position as attorney general. In a special meeting, the council voted 13 to 6 to terminate Branch’s employment, with no explanation provided during the session. This marked the end of Branch’s second term as attorney general. Deputy Attorney General Heather Clah will serve as the interim AG until a permanent replacement is named.
By submitting your comments, you hereby give AZPM the right to post your comments and potentially use them in any other form of media operated by this institution.